An AIP paleo coconut treat made with grass-fed gelatin and coconut cream. With only 3 simple ingredients, coconut jelly is sure to become a regular.
Early into my AIP diet, I needed a little something that would feel like a treat. However, there aren’t many choices for sweeteners while on an autoimmune protocol.
Since I’ve been a long time low carber, I wasn’t about to ruin that by adding in high carb natural sweeteners. I ended up doing The Meyers Way which allows stevia to be used.
I’ve never had issues with stevia, so I added some coconut stevia drops to up the flavor. That added just the right amount of sweetness to the coconut jelly and enhanced the flavor.
It’s said that stevia, even the powdered dry green leaves, may wreak havoc on hormones. Perhaps if you consume too much of it, but a little here and there shouldn’t be an issue.
To be safe, I avoided sweeteners of any kind while on my elimination diet. Instead, I’d just grab a handful of berries to sweeten my dairy free coconut yogurt or as a little snack.
It’s a good thing I like coconut because I ate a lot of it during my elimination phase. I’m at the 30 day mark now and I’m ready to start testing foods again.
I already know I have an egg white sensitivity, so I’ll continue to avoid them. But, egg yolks are very nutrient dense and don’t bother me so I’m looking forward to testing out a new custard recipe with coconut milk.
In addition to these bite sized coconut jelly treats, I also snacked on coconut wraps. They were like fruit roll-ups to me. I didn’t even bother using them to make a sandwich.
To keep myself well stocked with coconut cream, coconut milk, and coconut wraps, I’ve been shopping at Thrive Market. I also like to stock up on bone broth from Thrive.
If you do a lot of shopping, the yearly membership fee is well worth the cost. It’s like a wholesale market for natural and organic foods. And, their prices are much better than Amazon and come with free shipping if you order over $49.
The coconut cream I used in the coconut jelly is the Let’s Do Organic brand which doesn’t contain any guar gum. The gum is made from a seed which is avoided on AIP so I didn’t want it to interfere with the elimination.
Now that I’ve finished the elimination diet, I’ve started to reintroduce foods into my diet. Tomato is the first food that I tried and so far I haven’t had any obvious symptoms.
Although I did the AIP diet to calm down my immune system, an added benefit was that I lost six pounds without trying. I think those lingering pounds were sticking around because of food induced inflammation.
Today’s dairy has been shown to be very inflammatory so I doubt I’ll ever reintroduce it back into my diet. I do love cheese so I might see how I do with goat and sheep milk.
For those of you struggling with losing weight, I encourage you to give an elimination diet a try. It was a lot easier than I thought it would be. And it made me realize that I don’t need eggs, dairy, nuts, or seeds.
Despite the bad photos, I hope you give this coconut cream gelatin recipe a try. It’s an easy dairy free treat that’s quick and easy to make.
Low Carb AIP Paleo Coconut Jelly Recipe
Coconut Jelly - An easy AIP Treat
An AIP paleo coconut treat made with grass-fed gelatin and coconut cream. With only 3 simple ingredients, this coconut jello is sure to become a regular.
Ingredients
- 20 grams grass-fed gelatin about 2 tablespoons
- 1/2 cup water
- 1/2 cup hot water
- 27 ounces coconut cream 2 cans (13.5 ounces each)
- 1 teaspoon coconut stevia drops or preferred sweetener to taste (optional)
- 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract optional
Instructions
-
Soften gelatin in water for about a minute by sprinkling on top. Add hot water and stir well to dissolve.
-
Pour coconut cream into a medium saucepan. Heat on medium to a slow boil.
-
Add gelatin water to saucepan. Allow to cook for about 5 minutes. Remove from heat and stir in sweetener and or extract if using.
-
Pour into an 8x8-inch baking dish. Refrigerate until set.
Recipe Notes
To cut back on fat, you can use one can coconut milk and one can coconut cream. The cream does give a better flavor so I don't recommend using all coconut milk.
Related Posts
Bart says
Anyone have e issues with some of the gelatin settling while cooling in the fridge? Mine somewhat separated and I have about 2-4mm of clear gelatin on the bottom of the square. Also the squares are not as firm as I thought they would be. Still delicious though.
Lisa says
You have to make sure the gelatin dissolves completely. I’ve never had that issue.
Julia says
Please take into consideration that gelatin is made from bovine hoofs. They boil all those hoofs from the Slater house and boil them.
Lisa says
Fact: Gelatin is made from the bones, hides, and other parts of animals.
Mir says
Oh thank you for this!! I’ve been craving one of my favorite Hawaiian treats, Haupia, but all recipes use corn starch as a binder. I can’t wait to try this!
Lishka says
How long should it take to set up in the fridge? I put mine in there about an hour ago and mixture is about lukewarm now, but it’s still really, really sloshy. I’m getting worried because the taste I took off the spoon was yummy and I don’t want to waste it considering how much the coconut cream cost! I weighed out the gelatin, so I know I got the right amount. Should I quickly throw in some more?
Lisa says
It needs to set for at least 4 hours. If you weighed the gelatin, it should be okay.
Lishka says
Yep! I was worrying prematurely! It set up just fine. I had some for lunch today and it tastes amazing! Thanks so much!
Lisa says
Good to hear! Hope you love them as much as I do. I’m making another batch since it’s my favorite AIP treat.
Gina says
I want to make these…now. i don’t have a scale yet. What measurment in teaspoon is equal to 20 grams? I bought the Keto brand beef gelatin instead of the collagen peptides and want to make something beside gummies as I am not a fan of gummies. This question pertains to your coconut jelly recipe. Thanks!
Lisa says
It’s about 6.5 teaspoons based on this conversion.
Lovina says
What are you using for the coconut garnish i see in the pictures?
Lisa says
It’s just regular unsweetened dried shredded coconut.
Crystal says
You you need to wait for the mixture to cool before putting it inside the fridge?
Lisa says
You don’t. However, I wouldn’t add any kind of cover while it is cooling in the fridge.
Aly says
Just tried this recipe yesterday. Super easy and quick to make. The squares are delish by the way. Thank you so much for the recipe, Lisa! 🙂
Lisa says
You’re welcome Aly!
Michelle says
Thank you so much! I just made the recipe and it is setting up in my fridge. I did have a bit of trouble trying to soften the gelatin. Apparently I am clueless. If you have a spare minute would you be willing to share details about your process (please)? How much water to use? Thanks for all of your recipes and ideas.
Lisa says
If you have trouble, I recommend whisking it over the stove in a tiny pan. First, I sprinkle in the gelatin over water and let it soften for a minute or so. Then, I add the hot water and whisk briskly with a fork or whisk until completely dissolved.
Michelle says
Thanks for the reply and the great recipe. Even with my beginner gelatin skills the recipe turned out so amazing! Thanks!
Lisa says
Yay! 🙂
Jocelyne says
I’m not sure the calorie count for this is right. One can of coconut cream has over a thousand calories. My math says these would at least be 195 calories if broken into 12 servings.
Lisa says
I like to make them with 1 can coconut milk and 1 can coconut cream. However, this is the results provided by the calculator. I’ll double check it, though.