Get my 5-Ingredient Keto Cookbook featuring over 120 simple recipes!
Additional Info
No ice cream maker at home? Not a problem. It’s simple to make a no churn ice cream. Just take a look at this easy vanilla keto ice cream recipe without condensed milk.
What’s wrong with churning you ask? Nothing. After all, grass-fed butter, a staple of most keto diets, is made via churning, as is all butter.
But in order to enjoy ice cream that tastes just like you remember before you went Keto, you’d need an ice cream maker at home.
Most people don’t have ice cream makers at home for a few reasons. Firstly, the cost. Top-end home units run several hundred dollars.
Secondly, not everyone has the space. Thirdly, is the convenience factor.
It’s just easier for most people to go to an ice cream shop. But you can make an easy vanilla keto ice cream recipe at home.
But if you’re on a Ketogenic diet, the fourth reason is obviously that regular no churn ice cream is not keto-friendly.
So how do you make this simple keto-friendly frozen treat?
No Condensed Milk
The other problem with making your own keto ice cream is that most no churn recipes call for condensed milk.
The solution to making quick, homemade vanilla no churn ice cream without condensed milk is to whip an egg. The egg combines with the heavy whipping cream to simulate the texture of conventional dairy ice cream.
[Looking for a 100% dairy-free keto ice cream recipe? Check out my recipe for Keto Chocolate Dairy Free Ice Cream.]
If you’re new to the Keto lifestyle and wondering why condensed milk is a keto no-no, here’s why….
Even though this no churn ice cream recipe calls for heavy whipping cream, which is dairy, the cream is virtually all fat and no carbs. In comparison, the typical serving of condensed milk contains over 20 net grams of carbs.
Wouldn’t you rather get those 20 grams of net carbs from green leafy veggies and a handful of blueberries? (Say ‘yes’.)
Say No To Jell-O But Hello To Gelatin
You’ll see I also include gelatin in this vanilla no churn ice cream recipe without condensed milk.
But don’t confuse gelatin in this keto ice cream recipe with Jello-O gelatin from your childhood. Yes, Jell-O contains some gelatin.
Gelatin has become somewhat of a nutrition fad again. But thankfully, for healthier reasons than its being an ingredient in Jello-O.
Gelatin is derived from collagen. Collagen is animal protein that comes from the parts of cow, chicken, fish or pig that we don’t normally eat.
Although that may sound unappetizing, here’s why it’s good for you. It’s by consuming the collagen protein of other animals that we strengthen our own collagen.
Why do we need collagen?
Collagen is the most abundant protein in the body. About 30% of all the proteins that make you, well, you, are collagen.
Think of it as the glue that holds your skin, hair, nails, bones, muscles and the rest of your bodily tissue together. In fact, about 70% of your body’s tissue is collagen protein.
The problem is that after about age 30, your body’s collagen starts breaking down. And that’s why bone broth, gelatin and collagen protein have become so popular.
So why not add this amazing supplement to a vanilla no churn ice cream without condensed milk?
Now let’s get back to your childhood for a second. The reason why Jell-O isn’t healthy is three-fold…..
Firstly, the sugar content. A 3 oz. serving of Strawberry Jell-O contains, wait for it … a whopping 71 grams of sugar.
Secondly, there’s no dietary fat to slow down the massive insulin spike.
And third, Jell-O contains the artificial food dye.
But gelatin just by itself, which is collagen protein that’s been cooked, is healthy for you. And, it provides a thick texture to this vanilla keto ice cream recipe.
Advantages of Making Ice Cream at Home (with no ice cream maker)
Even the fanciest home ice cream maker requires a long churn cycle. But the advantage of making your own no churn ice cream is that you don’t have to wait for a machine to do it’s thing.
On the contrary, if you follow this no churn ice cream recipe, it will be ready to eat within a handful of hours. Just get some heavy whipping cream and an egg instead of using condensed milk.
Most foodies prefer the taste of organic vanilla extract from Madagascar instead of the lower quality variety that’s sold by large commercial spice retailers such as McCormick.
Another advantage of homemade ice cream is you get to control the ingredients, especially how sweet it is.
If you’re like me, the taste of most conventional ice cream tastes artificial.
But with this vanilla no churn ice cream recipe without condensed milk, I just use about 3/4 cup of a natural sugar alternative.
Just be careful to control the add-ins. And if you’re going to add anything extra, remember to factor in net carbs if you’re sticking with Keto.
A few organic chocolate chips are ok, but just watch out you don’t push yourself out of ketosis.
Actually, try my recipe first. I’m confident you won’t feel the need to add anything to this no low carb ice cream recipe. But, feel free to top it with some sugar free chocolate syrup if you’d like.
And this frozen low carb treat can also be used to make a copycat Shamrock Shake or Coffee Milkshake. Enjoy!
Sugar Free No Churn Vanilla Keto Ice Cream Recipe
Hope you enjoy this cool and refreshing low carb treat! And if you need a dairy-free version, just use coconut cream instead of heavy cream. Or, try my almond milk ice cream recipe!
You might also want to try serving this simple ice cream with sugar free caramel sauce.
★ FOLLOW ME ON FACEBOOK, PINTEREST AND INSTAGRAM FOR MORE EASY KETO RECIPES.
No Churn Vanilla Keto Ice Cream without Condensed Milk
Recipe Video (Click on Image to Play)
Ingredients
- 2 cups heavy cream
- 1 large egg
- 1 tablespoon vanilla extract
- 3.5 grams grass-fed gelatin about ½ tablespoon
- 3/4 cup low carb sugar substitute
- 1/2 teaspoon sea salt
Instructions
- Combine the heavy cream, egg, vanilla extract, gelatin, sweetener, and sea salt in medium saucepan over medium heat.
- Let the mixture cook until it begins to steep (strands of steam form on top of the heated liquid).
- Transfer the liquid to a heat-safe container and place it into your fridge for 60 to 70 minutes so the liquid can cool.
- After the base has cooled, pour it into a stand mixer or large bowl and use a hand mixer to beat the ice cream base until begins whip into soft peaks.
- Place the whipped ice cream into a freezer safe container, cover it, and let it freeze for at least 4 hours before serving.
Notes
Low Carb Sweeteners | Keto Sweetener Conversion Chart
Nutrition
Additional Info
Get Recipes Delivered Weekly
Join my email list and you’ll receive a free meal plan with 20 keto recipes. Plus, you can opt-in for special offers only for subscribers!
Note on Nutritional Information
Nutritional information for the recipe is provided as a courtesy and is approximate only. We cannot guarantee the accuracy of the nutritional information given for any recipe on this site. Erythritol carbs are not included in carb counts as it has been shown not to impact blood sugar. Net carbs are the total carbs minus fiber.
Unauthorized use of this material without written permission from Lisa MarcAurele is strictly prohibited unless for personal offline purposes.
Single photos may be used, provided that full credit is given to LowCarbYum.com along with a link back to the original content.
Liz
Hi. Can i use collagen peptides instead of gelatin?. Thanks.
Lisa MarcAurele
I’m not sure if collagen peptides has the same stabilizing properties. You could give it a try.
Krys
Okay so the picture looks amazing and having tried many low carb ice cream recipes I was thrilled to try this. I already mentioned that it didn’t whip up at all so I put it in the freezer and it came out rock hard just like every other recipe I have tried. The flavor was okay but benefits with a touch of salt.
Lisa MarcAurele
The taste and texture of low carb desserts can vary depending on the sweetener used. For the best texture, allulose and or inulin sweeteners are recommended. Homemade keto ice cream does tend to be quite hard after frozen so it’s best to let it sit out for 10 to 15 minutes before scooping. Salt is a flavor enhancer so it does tend to make the flavor taste better.
Krys
Followed the recipe exactly and it never “whipped into soft peaks” like…..at all….put in the freezer we will see how it tastes
Lisa MarcAurele
I find that you really just need to add volume to the mixture before freezing by whipping. Soft peaks aren’t essential.
Elle
Thank you for the recipe but I’m confused about the carb count. The 3/4 cup of Lakanto sweetener would be 177 carbs, as the sweetener is 1 carb for 1 gram, and 3/4 of a cup is approximately 177g. The recipe states that there are 3 carbs per serving and 4 servings for a grand total of 12 carbs for the entire recipe. Am I doing the math wrong? Thanks in advance!
Lisa MarcAurele
The erythritol isn’t included in the carb count as it’s been shown not to impact.
ALISA GUZAK
Made this to enjoy 4th of July while the hubby had Ben and Jerrys.
I added cocoa powder while hearing it up. It did not whip into soft peaks but did get thicker. After reading other comments, I wasn’t too worried (it tasted delish). I put into individual serving bowls (4) with some 75% dk choco chops and shredded coconut on top.
It was super good, tasted like a rich “mounds” mousse. That much heavy cream did a number on my belly. Will try coconut milk next time.
Diane
Is the 1 tablespoon vanilla extract correct? It seemed like a lot when I tasted it at the stage ready to cool. Mine’s not ready yet, it’s in the freezer so I haven’t tasted the final result.
Lisa MarcAurele
I like to use a lot for flavor and the alcohol helps too. But you can certainly cut it back if you’d like.
PJ
I obviously did something wrong. My ice cream was not creamy, kinda firm but foamy, kind of like frozen topping. Ideas?
Lisa MarcAurele
Did you whip the cream too much? It sounds like too much air.
Marcia
I just made this today. I am not happy with the gelatin texture…rather like a sponge! It would not whip up either….remained like a pudding. I will try it one more time without it and hope it is better. Otherwise, it has a good flavor and was pretty easy!
Larry
Where to get grass fed gelatin ??
Lisa MarcAurele
If you can’t find it, just use the regular kind like Knox brand.
Ruby
Health Food Store or online…NeoCell is a good company that has many grass fed gelatin products.
Dawn
Can I leave the mixture in the refrigerator until next day. Then whip it up and put in the freezer?
Lisa MarcAurele
I don’t think it would work because the gelatin would start to set. I suppose if you didn’t add the gelatin until just before mixing, it might work, but I would bloom the gelatin first (soften in water, then dissolve with some hot water).
Cynthia Armstrong
It did not whip for me either. I had a much longer post more detailed but when I submitted it stated this was spam… I assure you it is not spam.
Lisa MarcAurele
I’ve had times where it wouldn’t whip either but the ice cream still comes out delicious.
SHEILA L King
I only have lemon gelatin. Can I use it?
Lisa MarcAurele
If it’s sweetened, it might be too sweet and it will result in lemon ice cream. But if that’s not an issue, it should be okay. The gelatin is used as a stabilizer so the ice cream has a better texture and doesn’t freeze as hard.
Caro
I’m making it for the first time but with coconut cream as I can’t have lactose. It doesn’t seem to be thickening up after the chilling stage despite whisking til my arm is dead! Any tips? I added enough gelatin.
Lisa MarcAurele
It should be fine in the freezer. I’ve made this recipe with coconut cream. It should be fine once it freezes. However, the coconut cream version does freeze harder than the one made with heavy cream.
Theresa Elaigwu
Whatcan i substitute with Gellatin as i can’t find it in where i live.
Lisa MarcAurele
The gelatin is a stabilizer so you’ll want to use another like xanthan gum.
Stephanie Tidd
Can I use straight collagen instead of gelatin?
Thanks
Lisa MarcAurele
The gelatin is added as a stabilizer and collagen doesn’t have the same property. It should still work, but the ice cream might get icy.
Beppie from Holland :-)
I was so looking forward to this!
After cooling it for about 3 hours (because after 70 minutes is was still too warm, it finally became somewhat thicker in my standing mixer and I did a happy dance!
Unfortunately… the egg (I think..) started to make tiny lumps…
I did use the gelatin, and I wonder if that was the culprit instead of the egg…?
I did strain, because the gelatin also lumped a little in my saucepan.
Anyway, seemed a lot easier than it was 😉
It’s in the freezer now, lumps and all, the taste is great anyway 😉
Lisa
You do have to be careful with the temperature so the egg doesn’t start to cook and make lumps. It can be added in later and tempered by adding a small amount of the hot liquid and stirred in.
Aviva Boggs
Mine didn’t whip up. Got slightly thicker, so will see. Didn’t use gelatin, and forgot the strain it. Hope that doesn’t make much of a difference.
Lisa
The gelatin helps it whip up so that could have been an issue. Straining isn’t a big deal.
Unter der Laterne
There is a new fabulous natural sweetener called BOCHA SWEET . It keeps ice cream from becoming too hard .
One uses it in conjunction with SWERVE ( or erithritrol ). It MUST be used 50/50 , it can not be used by itself ! You will want to do that ,because Bocha Sweet is expensive. I only use for making ice cream !
Good luck and enjoy your creamy ice cream !
Lisa
Thanks for the tip! I’ll give it a try.
Fern
You use ¼ or ½ cup of whisky or vodka ( vodka will leave no taste) and the ice cream will be very smooth. I use bourbon.
Ivette Torres
Thanks for the tip. However, when it should be added? Before or after heating the mixture?
Tina
I wanted to make this recipe 1/2 chocolate. Do you think I could add cacao powder after the whipping stage to 1/2 of it, how much would you suggest?
Lisa
I’m thinking only a tablespoon or two.
Jenny
Hi how do I keep it from getting so hard you can’t scoop it? Following the recipe and that is the result. Comes out great and trastes amazing, but after an about 24 hours is super hard. 🙁
Lisa
I like to freeze it in small single serving containers. That way, it’s quick to soften just a serving.
Chris
If you add 1/2 cup of an alcohol (I like to use Crown Royal Vanilla) it helps keep the ice cream from going rock hard.
Lisa
I’ve added vodka before, but never that much. Maybe I just need to add more?
Chris
I have found 1/2 cup to be the magic amount, at least for me. Give it a try, it seems to be a matter of just playing around with measurements to see what works with your freezer temperature. By the way…this was a huge hit! Now my hubby’s favourite!
Lisa
Thanks for the tip! I’ll give it a try. I guess I just wasn’t adding enough alcohol.
Amber
Mine did not whip 🙁 ! Not sure what went wrong, I am hoping the gelatin will help make up for it? I did use egg yolks instead of an egg because they were leftover from another recipie but the whipping cream in the base should have still whipped?
Lisa
Egg whites do help as they are the part of the egg that whips up frothy. But, it should still work out okay even if it didn’t whip to soft peaks.
Fern
Mine did not whipped either, I followed the recipe to the letter and the ice cream never whipped to any peaks?
Joules Miller
I am hoping the gelatine I have will work …it’s Dr. Oetker fine leaf platinum ..100% pork?….many thanks…I’m in London so need some advice.
Lisa
It should be okay although I’m not familiar with the brand as I’ve never seen it here in the US.
Nancy
Any idea if it would work to use collagen instead of gelatin? Thanks.
Lisa
I haven’t tried that, but it should be okay but texture may be a bit different.
Erin Roher
I would love to try this recipe, is the sweetener required? I am trying to avoid extra sweeteners as well as sugar right now and was curious if would work the same. ?
Thanks!
Lisa
You may need more liquid (cream) to make up for the bulk. But, it should be okay to freeze without sweetener.
Twyla
Does this taste just as good without the gelatin?
Lisa
Gelatin is for texture and acts as a stabilizer. You can certainly leave it out, but I find the texture isn’t as creamy.
Ann
Can I substitute the gelatin with something else? Not available where i live.
Lisa
Agar agar might work as it’s often used instead of gelatin for vegans.
Debbie
I will taste today. However, mine did not whip up or it was very soft folds that didn’t hold up. Would it work to heat only 1/2 the heavy whipping cream and beat the other cup into peaked and then fold it into the mixture, maybe after cooling.
I also lined the freezer container with parchment paper as I saw this on another ice cream recipe.
The last no churn ice cream I made was hard as a rock. I let it sit out and then i was able to serve it. However, it seemed to have ice crystals in it. I’ll see what happens with this recipe.
Lisa MarcAurele
To get a more scoopable ice cream, I recommend using allulose sweetener if you have it. Fiber based sweeteners do better than erythritol based ones too. The mixture is heated to cook the eggs and dissolve the gelatin. You could try whipping some of the heavy cream to make the mixture fluffier. Temperature does have a lot to do with the ability to whip the mix.
Abby
HI,
This sounds great… going to make with my g’daughter. I’ve read about using glycerin in ice cream, I am wondering if you have heard of this ?
Thanks
Lisa
Yes. Glycerin helps keep it scoopable but it may add in some carbs so be careful. Also allulose sweetener does the same.
Rachel C
What kind of heavy cream are you using? All that I am have seen when shopping heavy cream is cream that has a half a gram to 1 gram. That sounds great, however; it is for a table spoon serving. You are calling for 2 cups, that could be anywhere from 16 to 32 carbs. That’s my whole days worth of carbs. Any help you can offer, a true low-carb ice cream would be amazing!!!
Lisa
Heavy cream should have about 6 grams carbs per cup.
Juleanne
Look for heavy whipping cream, not heavy cream
Beth
How would you change the directions for someone who has an ice cream machine?
Lisa
Once the mixture cools, you should be able to process in an ice cream maker. If you want it to have more air, you could whip it up first, but that shouldn’t be necessary.
Patricia
Do you think this would work with coconut cream. I have to be dairy free
Lisa
I’ve been avoiding dairy too and coconut cream has been a good sub in other ice cream recipes. I just haven’t tried it in this one, but I do believe it will be okay.
Charlene
Whipping an egg is genius ! Thank you, Lisa.! I’ve been looking for a no machine type of recipe that doesn’t have me stirring the mixture every 5 minutes while it freezes in the freezer, which sounds unreasonable… not to mention hard on my arm, lol! This recipe sounds like it uses old fashioned ingenuity instead of testy machinery or nearly impossible methods. I’m trying this soon and I have a feeling it will be with me for many years! Thank you sooo much. 🙂
Lisa
Hope you love it as much as I do Charlene!